The Permission Problem: When Staff Wait for Authorization They Already Have

This episode of the Healthy Church Staff podcast, hosted by Todd Rhoades, addresses the issue of unclear decision-making authority within church staff, which hampers productivity and fosters frustration. Todd provides strategies for defining clear decision-making boundaries to empower staff and encourage more independent decision-making. • Unclear decision-making authority paralyzes church staff and hinders productivity. • Staff continually seek unnecessary approvals out of fear of overstepping boundaries. • A clear framework for decision-making authority can resolve confusion and empower staff. • Defining specific spending limits and areas of autonomy for staff is recommended. • Encourages leaders to allow staff to make decisions and learn from mistakes. • Todd stresses the importance of fostering innovation by reducing micromanagement.

Have questions or comments?  Send to podcast@chemistrystaffing.com

Be sure to subscribe to The Healthy Church Staff Podcast wherever you regularly listen to podcasts.

- - - - -

Is Your Church Hiring?
If your church is searching for a new staff member, reach out to Todd for a conversation on how he might be able to help.

Are You Looking for a New Ministry Role?
If you are open to a new church role in the next few months, add your free resume and profile at ChemistryStaffing.com.

Transcript

Quick Intro And Sponsor Context

Church Leadership Radar Announcement

The Permission Spiral Scenario

How Micromanagement Kills Innovation

A Simple Authority Framework

The Freedom Test For Leaders

Jesus Model Of Delegated Authority

This Week’s Delegation Challenge

How To Reach Us And Closing

SPEAKER_00 0:08

Many church staff members are just absolutely paralyzed by unclear decision-making authority, constantly seeking approval for things that they should have been empowered to handle independently a long time ago. And it's hurting productivity and frustrating everybody involved. Believe me. And we're going to talk about that today, right here on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. Hi there, my name's Todd Rhodes, along with Matt Steen, and one of the co-founders over at chemistrystaffing.com. I hope you'll check us out over there. And I'm your host here every weekday on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. Hey, before we get started today, I've been telling you this week about a brand new website that I've just released. It's called churchleadershipradar.com. And you can go there. It's a daily email newsletter. It has a lot of things that we can't cover every day, believe it or not, here on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. But it has current news items from the past 24 hours in the church world. It has a bunch of brand new resources that I've found all over the internet for you that I think would just be really interesting. Reads, it will hopefully you will come out each day a little bit smarter, a little bit more well informed, and this will translate into you being a better church staff member. So check it out over at churchleadershipradar.com and also in in a little trickier. There's also a podcast that is launching every day. And this is an interesting little project. This does not feature me, but it features my AI twin Ted Rhodes. So you'll want to check that out over at churchleadershipradar.com. All right, today we're going to continue our conversations about things that hopefully are really interesting for you as church staff members. And let me give you this scenario. Your worship pastor texts you last night at 9 p.m. He says, Hey, can I move the communion table three feet to the left for this Sunday? And then it's Saturday night, and your children's pastor emails you about buying a$12 pack of construction paper, and your youth pastor asks permission to schedule a pizza night. Meanwhile, you're drowning in decisions that actually matter, at least what you think matters, and your staff feels like they can't even breathe without asking first. So here's what's really happening here. Your staff isn't being lazy, they're not being overly cautious, but they're operating in kind of a fog of unclear authority. Nobody knows where their line is. So they ask about everything because getting in trouble for overstepping is worse than being annoying. Okay, and this can create a vicious cycle. I've seen it happen many times in churches, smaller churches where everything rises to the level of senior pastor, larger churches where everything rises to the level of the executive pastor or the supervisor. And it's a permission spiral. Everybody starts making every decision because it's faster than explaining. Staff stops thinking critically because you'll just decide anyway. And you get frustrated that nothing happens without you. And they get frustrated that they can't move without any kind of permission from you. And in the process, it just is an exhausting way that innovation dies. Innovation goes to die when there is this much adversion to making factuals. Innovation dies because risk requires approval. Your team becomes order takers and not leaders. Now, I know, Todd, you're saying this is not what I want. I know your heart's right. You want to protect the church. You're probably put some of these safeguards in because there were some bad decisions that were made in the past and you want to avoid chaos. But it could be that you're accidentally creating the very dysfunction that you're trying to prevent. So today I want to help you out. If you have this problem in your church, hopefully this authority framework that I'm going to share with you here in the next couple of minutes will help you. Okay. First thing is draw some clear lines around decision-making authority. You own these decisions, you inform me about these decisions, you ask me about these decisions. Put dollar amounts maybe on spending authority. Hey, if it's over$50, yeah, come and ask. Or if it's over$500, over whatever your context is, but maybe putting a dollar amount on spending authority. Make sure it's in their budget, of course. But maybe give them permission to fail on some small things without coming to you. Tell them explicitly, hey, this is yours. This is yours to own. You do what you need to do within the confines of the authority that I've given you and the decisions that you can make and your budget, but this is yours to own. And then stop rescuing decisions that they should be making on their own. Part of this could just be a simple freedom test, right? What's the worst thing? This is something that you can ask yourself. What's the worst thing happens if they decide this wrong? That's where that authority framework comes in. You don't want them making a really bad decision on a$50,000 expenditure, right? That's not what I'm talking about. But I'm talking about if they want to move the communion table over or if they want to buy some construction paper or they want to get a new$50 a month program that's going to help them with their ministry area, don't make them get approval if they if what's the worst thing that can happen? Ask yourself that. What's the worst thing that can happen if they get this wrong? If the answer is not catastrophic, let them own it. Your worship pastor can probably handle that communic community table placement. Your children's pastor knows about how much construction paper costs and how much they need. Most decisions are reversible. Okay. And most even if it's a bad decision, most bad decisions are reversible, and most bad decisions really don't have that big of a consequence. Not as big as we think that they do. Think about how Jesus operated with his disciples, right? He sent them out with authority to heal and to teach, and he did not micromanage their every conversation. He gave them the framework and he trusted the outcome, and that's the leadership that multiplies. So here's your bottom line for today. Clear authority creates confident staff, and confident staff create healthy momentum and confident staff when given the proper authority framework. I was gonna say nine times out of ten, maybe it's not that much, but most of the time they're gonna make well-informed, healthy, and good decisions. So here's the challenge this week. I want you to write down three decisions that your staff keeps bringing to you. And maybe you can't even think of them now, but just put a legal pad on your desk for crying out loud. And whenever somebody comes in and asks your opinion or asks you to make a decision, write that down. And then ask yourself, is this a decision that I really needed to be in the loop on, or is this a decision that they could have saved my time and theirs by just making the decision? Then have individual conversations where you explicitly give them authority over those decisions and say the words, this is yours to own. Your staff really wants to leave. Give them the clarity to do it. I hope this has helped. I'd love to have a conversation with you. Either online, you can email me podcast at chemistry staffing.com. If there's any way that I can help you, or any of my team over at Chemistry Staffing can help you, hiring, firing staff, compensation data, any kind of healthy church staff initiative, any place you're stuck on your staff, anything you just need advice on, reach out to me, podcast at chemistry staffing.com. And if you want to listen to the brand new Churchleadershipradar.com podcast, it comes out every Monday through Saturday, actually, with my AI twin brother, Ted Rhodes. Yeah, Ted Rhodes, you're gonna want to head over to churchleadershipradar.com, pop in your name and your email address, and we'll send you the free email newsletter that also has a link to the daily podcast there as well. All right, that's it for today. Hope you'll join me right back here again tomorrow on the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. And tomorrow, what are we talking about tomorrow? We're gonna talk about when the church falls and rises again. That'll be an interesting one. Hope you'll join me right back here on the Healthy Church Stafford.